Judge.me vs Yotpo - Which Review Platform Is Better for Your Ecommerce Brand?
Judge.me is great if you want a simple, predictable review tool that’s easy to run. Yotpo makes more sense if you want reviews built into a larger retention system with loyalty, referrals, SMS, and UGC. Both work the same way inside a MobiLoud app, so the decision comes down to how broad you want your stack to be.
Judge.me is great if you want a simple, predictable review tool that’s easy to run. Yotpo makes more sense if you want reviews built into a larger retention system with loyalty, referrals, SMS, and UGC. Both work the same way inside a MobiLoud app, so the decision comes down to how broad you want your stack to be.
Choosing a reviews platform feels easy at first—until you actually have to pick one. The wrong choice adds bloat or limits you later, and the right one quietly powers half your customer journey.
If you run an ecommerce brand, you already know how much reviews matter. They build trust, speed up decisions, and keep customers coming back.
Judge.me and Yotpo are the two tools most teams end up debating. They solve the same problem, but they’re built for very different kinds of stores. Judge.me keeps things simple and predictable. Yotpo folds reviews into a larger system with loyalty, referrals, SMS, and UGC.
This guide breaks down how each tool works, where they’re strongest, and which one actually fits your setup.
What Is Judge.me?
Judge.me is a reviews platform that helps ecommerce stores collect and display customer feedback. It supports product reviews, star ratings, photos, videos, and Q&A.
The platform works with Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, and several other ecommerce systems.
Judge.me offers a set of on-site widgets, including star ratings, full review sections, carousels, media grids, and trust badges.
You can place them on product pages, collection pages, homepages, and landing pages. All widgets sync from the Judge.me dashboard and follow the styling of the store.
Judge.me also connects with popular tools in the ecommerce stack, such as Klaviyo, Gorgias, PageFly, and loyalty apps. This allows teams to send review requests through more channels, show ratings in more places, and tie review activity into other workflows.
What Is Yotpo?
Yotpo is a retention and UGC platform used by ecommerce brands on Shopify, BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, and other major ecommerce platforms. Reviews are one part of the product, alongside modules for loyalty, referrals, and customer photos and videos.
The reviews module supports written reviews, star ratings, photos, videos, and Q&A.
Yotpo displays this content through on-site widgets such as review sections, star ratings, carousels, and media galleries. You can manage all widgets from the Yotpo dashboard and adjust to the styling of the store.
Beyond reviews, Yotpo includes loyalty programs, referral programs, and ways to manage customer photos and videos.
These modules connect with marketing platforms like Klaviyo, Attentive, Gorgias, and subscription systems. Teams can link customer reviews, loyalty activity, and messaging flows in one place.
Judge.me vs. Yotpo Compared
Judge.me and Yotpo take very different approaches to reviews. This quick comparison makes the differences clear at a glance.
Features
Both platforms help brands collect and display customer feedback, but they take different approaches. Judge.me focuses on simple, reliable review collection with lightweight UGC tools. Yotpo combines reviews with loyalty programs, referral programs, and tools to manage customer photos and videos.
Review Collection and Automation
Judge.me sends email review requests and can send SMS requests when paired with your SMS tool. It collects text, photo, and video reviews and lets you control timing, reminders, and publish rules from one place.
If you want reviews to run on autopilot with minimal setup, Judge.me is the easier fit. If you want tighter control over what gets published and how customers respond, Yotpo gives you more tools.
Yotpo sends email review requests and can connect with SMS platforms through integrations. Teams can add prompts that shape what customers write and use tighter rules for what gets published automatically.
Display and Customization
Judge.me includes star ratings, review sections, carousels, media grids, Q&A, and trust badges. Widgets follow your theme across product pages, collections, and landing pages.
Yotpo offers similar widgets with extra layouts built for brands that get a lot of customer photos and videos. Its galleries and UGC blocks give teams more control over how customer photos and videos show up on the page.
If you sell skincare and customers upload lots of before-and-after photos, Yotpo’s gallery tools give you far more room to showcase that content.
UGC: Photos, Videos, and Social Proof
Judge.me collects photo and video reviews and displays them through grids or carousels. The Unboxed feature adds curated UGC galleries.
Yotpo gives teams a workspace to collect, tag, and sort customer photos and videos. It also imports media from social channels and lets you turn customer photos into galleries that link straight to products.
Analytics and Reporting
Judge.me covers core metrics like review volume, ratings, and request performance.
If you only need the basics — how many reviews you’re getting and how well requests work — Judge.me is enough. If you want to understand what customers are actually saying and how it ties into loyalty, Yotpo goes further.
Yotpo offers reporting that highlights common themes, keyword trends, and how customers engage with your UGC. If you use loyalty, it also connects review data with your loyalty activity.
For a deeper look at what Shopify review apps offer, explore the top options and choose the right fit for your brand.
Integrations
Both platforms support the major ecommerce systems and the marketing tools most teams use. The difference is how far each one reaches in your stack.
Judge.me works with Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, Magento, Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Gorgias, PageFly, and many loyalty apps. These integrations help teams pull review data into emails, support tickets, and custom page layouts.
Yotpo connects with Shopify Plus, BigCommerce, Adobe Commerce, Salesforce Commerce Cloud, and tools like Klaviyo, Attentive, Gorgias, Recharge, and CDPs. This works well for stores that want reviews, loyalty, UGC, and SMS under one roof.
Ease of Use and Setup
Judge.me installs fast on all platforms. Most teams configure it in under an hour because everything sits in one simple dashboard. Reviews on Capterra and Trustpilot often mention easy onboarding and minimal maintenance.
Yotpo also installs quickly, but setup gets more involved once you add UGC, loyalty, or SMS. Reviews alone are simple. Adding UGC, loyalty, or SMS introduces extra steps and a learning curve before everything feels natural.
G2 reviews frequently point out that the platform is powerful but has a lot of settings to learn.
Performance and Reliability
Judge.me loads lightweight widgets that match the store’s theme. They appear quickly on Shopify, BigCommerce, and WooCommerce, and syncing is fast. CDN delivery keeps widgets stable during traffic spikes.
Yotpo loads reliably too, but widgets load more slowly when you’re pulling in large galleries or lots of customer photos. Stores with lots of customer photos and videos may see slightly slower load times. A global CDN keeps load times steady even when traffic spikes.
Support and Community
Judge.me offers chat and email support. Documentation covers setup, widgets, and integrations. Many merchants mention fast replies and helpful guidance. The community is especially strong among Shopify users.
Yotpo provides chat and email support as well, and higher plans include a customer success manager. Its community includes many mid-market and enterprise brands using several Yotpo tools. The documentation covers everything from reviews to loyalty to UGC, so there’s more to sort through.
Pricing
Judge.me
- Free plan
- Awesome plan: $15 per month
- Unlimited reviews on both plans
- Customization and all integrations included in the paid plan
- Pricing does not change with order volume
Yotpo
- Starter: $79 per month (up to 500 orders)
- Pro: $169 per month (up to 500 orders)
- Premium: custom pricing
- Bundles available for Reviews, UGC, Loyalty, and SMS
- Pricing varies with modules and order volume
When to Choose Judge.me
Judge.me is a practical fit for teams that want a straightforward reviews solution without managing extra modules. It works well for stores that want to collect feedback quickly and display it across product pages with minimal setup.
Choose Judge.me if your team wants:
- A simple reviews tool without additional retention features
- Predictable, low-cost pricing regardless of order volume
- Fast installation on Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, or Magento
- Review widgets that work across product pages, collections, and landing pages
- Basic UGC tools such as media grids and carousels
- Easy integrations with email, support, and loyalty tools already in your stack
- A lightweight dashboard that’s simple to manage day to day
Judge.me fits stores that prioritize speed, clarity, and a focused review workflow.
When to Choose Yotpo
Yotpo is a better fit for teams that want reviews as part of a wider customer retention setup. It works well for brands that rely on customer photos and videos, loyalty programs, and referral flows that connect with their email and SMS platforms.
Choose Yotpo if your team wants:
- A platform that combines reviews, UGC, loyalty, and referrals
- More control over media-heavy galleries and how your customer photos appear across your site
- Guided review prompts and more detailed auto-publish controls
- Stronger enterprise integrations, including Shopify Plus, Adobe Commerce, and Salesforce Commerce Cloud
- Support for CDPs like Segment or mParticle
- Built-in loyalty tools that connect reviews with rewards and customer profiles
- Broader analytics that cover reviews, UGC, and retention activity
Yotpo fits stores that treat reviews as one part of a larger customer experience strategy.
If you want to go deeper into choosing the right loyalty tool for your Shopify store, explore our full guide to the top Shopify loyalty apps.
Integrating Judge.me or Yotpo in Your Mobile App
Loyalty, reviews, and UGC are crucial parts of a mobile app too.
If your brand runs a mobile app, your reviews and loyalty tools should function in the app exactly as they do on your site.
Luckily, with MobiLoud, that's not an issue. MobiLoud works flawlessly with both Yotpo and Judge.me.
There's no extra integration required, no extra setup, and no sacrificing key features.
Everything works in the app just as it does on your site. That's why brands love MobiLoud. It’s the only way to guarantee your site’s features carry over to your mobile app.
Learn more about why MobiLoud is the best way to build ecommerce apps.
Which Review Platform Is Better for Your Ecommerce Brand?
The better choice depends on what your team needs. Judge.me is a good fit if you want a simple, low-cost reviews tool that is easy to run. Yotpo fits brands that want reviews to sit inside a broader retention system with UGC, loyalty, referrals, and SMS.
Both tools work inside a MobiLoud app exactly as they do on your website. All widgets, forms, and review flows carry over automatically, and any updates you make on the site sync straight into the app.
Get a free preview to see how your reviews would look inside a real mobile app.
FAQs
Convert your website into a mobile app
